A
Laodicean, first published in 1880/1881, is one of
Thomas Hardy’s lesser-known novels as it lacks the gut-wrenching tragedy of The
Mayor of Casterbridge (1886); Tess of the d’Urbervilles (1891); Jude
the Obscure (1895) etc. Still, it is a fascinating read as it thematically revolves
around a sense of the remnants of the pre-modern world being lost, and the confusion/psychological
pain that this process brings. The latter is mainly seen through Hardy’s
portrayal of one of the central characters of the novel, Paula Power.
Throughout the novel, Paula suffers from
an internal struggle between having a nostalgic longing for the nobility and
aesthetic beauty of the medieval world, symbolised by the old castle that she has
inherited from her late father, and recognising that the remnants of this world
have been eclipsed by a simpler, drab, but more comfortable modern world.
Intermingled with all this is Paula’s growing relationship with the young budding
architect and Romantic figure of George Somerset. Paula is first encountered in
an early scene where she is about to be baptised into the Baptist faith but
cannot go through with this act of formal religious transition. All of this is
observed with interest by Somerset who seems to be a bit of a religious seeker,
himself, which becomes more apparent in another early scene where he uses New
Testament extracts and arguments from early Church fathers to defend infant
baptism against the protestations of the Baptist minister, Mr. Woodwell. In
response, the latter claims that Paula is “vulnerable to the Medieval
influences” of her castle.
Still early on in the novel, Paula tells
Somerset that she isn’t a “medievalist” but more of a “Greek”. After Hardy
describes the “stagnation” and redundancy of Stancy Castle chapel, in another
scene, Woodwell informs Somerset that Paula was receiving visits from “people
of old cavalier families” who believed in “Apostolic Succession”; was influenced
by her close friend, Charlotte De Stancy, whose family had lost their
aristocratic standing; and had never forgiven Woodwell, himself, for a sermon
in which he had compared her to “the church at Laodicea” (a church in St. John’s
Book of the Apocalypse/Book of Revelation renowned for being lukewarm in
belief). In the second half of the novel, Woodwell tells Somerset that Paula
has moved away from her “family creed of Calvinistic truth” towards the more
classical De Stancy worldview. During a quiet moment, Somerset reflects on
Paula being a “personification of the modern spirit”, but he also recognises
that she is influenced by a “chink of medievalism” which prompts some kind of “Romanticism”
inside her.
The action of the novel heats up in the
last 60-70 pages, with some of the most pivotal scenes being set in France. In
one key scene, Charlotte De Stancy’s brother (and George Somerset’s rival for
Paula) accompanies Paula to a cathedral in Paris, possibly Notre-Dame. De
Stancy points out that Paula’s roundhead ancestors had destroyed his ancestors’
castle, plus the statues and stained glass in a (probably high church) cathedral,
and yet she was now heading towards a Catholic cathedral. As the pair enter the
cathedral, the “evening darkness” is “scarcely broken” by a few “dotted about
candles”. After a while, they move to the choir section where they are greeted
with a “blaze of light, partly from the altar” and “more particularly” from the
image of a saint who some people “had assembled to honour” which was
“surrounded by candles” and many “flowering plants”. Here, a “secondary
radiance” from the candles is “reflected upward into their faces by the
polished marble pavement” which is only “interrupted” by the “shady forms of
the officiating priests”. Moreover, Paula points out that the women competing
to regain their flower pots near the saint’s image spoils the “solemn effect” of
what had gone on before. When De Stancy accuses Paula of being a “‘harsh
Puritan’”, she reveals that she’s often accused of being “‘worldly’” and “‘half-and-half’”,
which reintroduces the recurring theme
of Paula not quite being anything concrete in belief. For me, this church scene
is fascinating as Hardy describes it in almost theatrical terms, and as a
non-Catholic, he seems to be scratching at the surface of certain aesthetic
aspects that accompany Catholic religious practice. In response, I have often
wondered that if Hardy had dug further into this aesthetic dimension, he may
have become interested in Catholic doctrines, and who knows what this may have
lead to.
A little later on, Paula goes looking for
Somerset and the “beauties” of architecture in Lisieux. Despite having to pass some
“dreary suburban erections” from “the railway to the old quarter of town”, Paula
knew that Somerset would be working at one of the “medieval buildings”. She
then visits a “large church” which would have made “any Gothic architect take
lodgings in its vicinity for a fortnight”. Having failed to find Somerset at
the monumental church of St. Jacques, Paula becomes enchanted by a “steep
narrow street of antique character”, and is “transported to the Middle Ages”
encountering a scene that a “medievalist” would “revel in” and “die and be
buried in”. For Paula, this street is the living personification of the “imaginations
of antiquarians” with “smells from” the 16th century hanging in the
air “in all their original integrity and without a modern taint”. Thus, while
surrounded by such medieval grandeur, Paula appears to have some kind of epiphany
through which she gains a connection with an old world not completely lost.
While still seeking the elusive Somerset in
Caen, Paula visits a church near her hotel to help pass away a “dull
dispiriting evening”. Inside, the church is only lit by “seven candles burning
before the altar” of a side chapel, with the “mass of the building being in
deep shade”, and some “motionless outlines” slowly revealing themselves to be
“kneeling women”. Momentarily, the unlocking of a confessional door by a priest
“sounded in the silence”. After a short while, a priest leads Paula to the room
of Mr. Cockton, Somerset’s assistant. Cockton reveals that Somerset “was sick
and tired of holy places” and was striving to find “‘some wicked spot or other”
to attain some “consolation which holiness could not give’”, although he may
not have really meant this. Hence, Somerset may have become disillusioned
through losing the motivation to pursue a medieval or Romantic outlook lost in past
time. In contrast, Paula does not seem able to shake off her pursuit of Romantic
experience and perception.
When finally catching up with Somerset,
Paula is told that she is “an enigma always”, and she acknowledges that
Somerset “‘knows a good many fibres’” of her character fearing that “‘some
uncanny influence of the dead De Stancys would drive” her away “from him” again.
In another turn of events, Charlotte De Stancy sends Paula a letter revealing
that she has joined a “‘Protestant sisterhood’” so as “‘to steal’” herself away
from the modern “‘social world’” that she rejects to attain a “‘resting place
till the great rest comes’”. In her “‘secluded home’”, Charlotte promises to be
even more devoted to her “‘very best friend’” with “‘continuing love and
friendship’” as Paula would “‘always be’” somehow with her. In response,
Paula weeps at Charlotte’s decision, and Somerset tries to console her by
saying that Charlotte “‘was genuine, if anybody ever was’”. Here, Somerset may
be suggesting that Charlotte is not a social actor, with the latter role possibly
being a prerequisite for living in an
increasingly modern world. Regarding this, Paula views herself as a “‘representative
of the new aristocracy of internationality”, while Charlotte represents an
“‘old aristocracy of exclusiveness’”. Moreover, Paula acknowledges that she is
what “‘poor Mr. Woodwell said’”, a Laodicean from the Book of the
Apocalypse/Book of Revelation, a “‘neither cold nor hot’” person who cannot
submit his/her will to believe in things strongly. Reflecting on her modern
self, Paula believes that for her, “‘lukewarmth is not an accident but a
provisional necessity’”, recognising that even people’s “‘best emotions’” are
only “‘transitory’”.
After De Stancy Castle is burnt down,
Paula and Somerset decide against “‘rebuilding’” it unless “compelled” to do
so. Moreover, they decide to leave “the edifice in ruins” and to live in a
“mansion of independent construction” near “the old one” to be “unencumbered with the ghosts of an
unfortunate line”. To emphasise this, Somerset tells Paula that the “winter
rains will soon wash away the unsightly smoke from the walls”, with De Stancy
Castle becoming “‘beautiful in its decay’”. He also predicts that Paula will recover
from a mental “‘warp’” caused by the “‘medievalism’” of the “‘place’”. In
response, Paula questions whether she can ever perfectly accept and represent the
“‘modern spirit’”, wishing that Somerset was a De Stancy and that her castle
had not been burnt down. Thus, Paula cannot become a fully modern person
because she cannot completely let go of her pursuit of a medieval or Romantic
ethos, being trapped between the drab reality of her real, current world and a
nostalgic longing for a more heroic world that has been lost in past time.
Here, Thomas Hardy seems to be diagnosing a central feature of the melancholia
suffered by sentient modern people who seek a return to something more beautiful,
heroic, and metaphysical. Of course, Hardy’s focus on the destructive effects
of modern human melancholia is far more pronounced in his great tragedies: The
Woodlanders (1887) and The Return of the Native (1878), and
especially The Mayor of Casterbridge (1886), Tess of the d’Urbervilles
(1891), and Jude the Obscure (1895). But all this is another story,
of course.