Thursday 2 December 2021

Charles Taylor's A Secular Page - Three Quarters Through



      Taylor (2007) records the massive changes that have occurred in Western religious practice from pre-Reformation, medieval times up to the modern-day, with a fall in Western religious practice and rise of (materialist/humanist) unbelief narratives being clearly visible, especially over the past 200-300 years. In great detail, Taylor (2007) discusses the many complex twists and turns of the latter phenomena, with it being far from a straightforward linear process of scientific discovery and technological innovation making religious practice redundant, as the latter mutates and survives, albeit in shrunken form. Moreover, Taylor (2007) repeatedly points towards a pro-secularist ideological outlook which denigrates religious practice having been necessary, alongside scientific discovery, technological innovation, mass movement to big urban environments etc., to make religion less meaningful in many people’s lives and minds. Interestingly, the upshot of all this is what Taylor (2007) refers to as a “super-nova” effect through which most people in the West are now exposed to almost limitless amounts of belief and unbelief systems, which increasingly makes a traditional handing down of a particular religion from generation to generation more difficult and increasingly a thing of the past.

      In Taylor’s (2007) account, some of the many significant historical processes, situations, and episodes that he deals with include:

- pre-Reformation/pre-Counter Reformation Catholicism

- 16th century Reformation/Birth of Protestantism (Anglicans, Calvinists, Lutherans, Anabaptists etc.)

- 16th/17th century Counter-Reformation (e.g. the Catholic Church shaking off local, folk-level superstitions)

- 17th century: European Catholic-Protestant religious wars coming to an end; Descartes (1596-1650) opening the way for the Enlightenment

- 18th century: Kant (1724-1804) pushing the Enlightenment forward; the French Revolution (1789) destroying the idea of national monarchy; the 1789 American Constitution allowing greater individual liberty and less state interference than European political formats; the Industrial Revolution and mass movement from the countryside to towns/cities; and the birth of smaller Protestant denominations (e.g. Methodists)

- 19th century: Ongoing development of Romanticism (Blake, Wordsworth, Coleridge etc.); Second Great (Protestant) Religious Awakening and Birth of Mormonism in early 19th century; Darwin’s (1809-1882) theory of evolution and Karl Marx’s (1818-1883) egalitarian socio-economic theory prompting accelerated growth of unbelief options etc.

- 20th century: 1917 Russian Bolshevik Revolution (birth of state communism); the mass death of the First (1914-1918) and Second World Wars (1939-1945); Bloomsbury Group and Frankfurt School (critical theory) attacking Classical ideas in Western academia; post-War questioning of ideological and religious meta-narratives; the 1960s Cultural/Sexual Revolution, Second Vatican Council, and ongoing rebellion against traditional moral/religious values.

- 21st century: the accelerated spread of woke/globalist ideology and ideological attacks against the remnants of Christianity; an attempted push-back against woke/globalist ideology.

While reading this great book, I continually find myself using a pen to focus my attention better and do the book justice:


I also tend to read the book just after midday, while I'm cooking dinner, when my mind is usually at its sharpest.

No comments:

Post a Comment